15 Most Expensive Magic Cards (2019 Edition)

Most Expensive Magic Cards
The legendary, mortgage-paying power nine.

The rarest, most sought after Magic cards of the past command astounding prices. 

When Magic came to gaming in 1993 no one would have predicted it’s meteoric success. It became an international sensation, with the demand for new cards never satisfied for long. As new cards are printed and old ones slip into legend, prices change. Older cards in demand command the highest prices in magic as they are at the pinnacle of rarity.

The 15 most expensive magic cards are from the Alpha set, with two exceptions. Volcanic Island, the island-mountain which was to be printed in Alpha, was accidentally left out of the print sheet. As such it’s listed price is from Beta, the earliest available printing. The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale is from the Legends expansion.

Most of these cards are also members of the power nine. The nine most powerful relics of Magic’s past. These include the five Moxen, Timetwister, Time Walk, Ancestral Recall and Black Lotus.

The prices listed here are fair market prices that assume a card of good quality traded in an open market. A card is valued for demand, supply, and then condition.\

15. The Tabernacle at Pendrell Vale (Legends)

Tabernacle is primarily used in Lands, an archetype of decks that wins with lands and support spells. 

Most Magic games involve creatures staying out for multiple turns and attacking. Paying to keep those creatures alive makes you have to choose between keeping your boardstate and developing it further. This puts you at half-pace with your opponent. Getting stuck in this trap is exactly how to lose a game of Magic.

In magic there are questions and answers, you win with questions and you save yourself with answers. There are few questions as hard to answer as Tabernacle, and it is in an answer to many questions. Many control decks could find no better way to control the board. However, its early place in the history of the game and land subtype demand a high price - $2,000 for a near-mint copy. If you can find one.

More on this topic:


Alex traverses the multiverse in search of a greater understanding of storytelling. His Int is higher than his Dex and he’s put most of his skill points into writing, survival and arcana.
Gamer Since: 1997
Favorite Genre: RPG
Currently Playing: Torment: Tides of Numenera, Bloodborne
Top 3 Favorite Games:Baldur's Gate, Dark Souls: Prepare To Die Edition, Mass Effect 2

Latest Comments

1 Gamers Commented on this game. ADD YOURS.

You must login to post comments.
500 characters remaining

All Comments (1)

CMClassy's picture

CMClassy 5 years 6 months ago

Cardboard being worth thousands of dollars will never cease to amaze me. As much as WOTC would love to do away with the Reserved list, the people obsessed with collecting and maintaining value are causing trouble in that front. Legacy and Vintage are forever inaccessible because of it.

More Top Stories